Are Asphalt Millings Bad for the Environment?

The Federal Highway Administration reports that more than 97 percent of reclaimed asphalt mixture went into new pavement. Even so, buyers still ask whether millings can harm soil and water. The studies give a conditional answer.

Quick Answer

Asphalt millings are reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP). Two Florida laboratory studies, from 1999 and 2022, report different leaching results. The 1999 study found lead slightly above a drinking water standard in RAP from older roadways. The 2022 report found risk-based threshold exceedances in some samples but called the risk minimal. Neither gives a field verdict.

What Asphalt Millings Are and How Much Gets Reused

Asphalt millings are reclaimed asphalt pavement, or RAP, which is old asphalt that has been removed and reprocessed. The FHWA reports that more than 97 percent of asphalt mixture reclaimed from old pavements was used in new pavement. The average RAP share in asphalt mixtures by weight rose from 15.6 percent in 2009 to 21.1 percent.

If you plan a millings surface, the Asphalt Millings Calculator estimates the tons to order. The tool does the volume arithmetic. It does not answer the environmental question.

Here is the tool’s worked example for 500 square feet at a 4 inch finished depth, using the placed density of 1.50 tons per cubic yard.

  1. Volume. 500 x 4 / 324 = 6.17 cubic yards.
  2. Tons. 6.17 x 1.50 = 9.26 tons, before any overage.
  3. Order with overage. 9.26 + 10 percent (0.93) = 10.19 tons to order.

This is planning arithmetic, not a recommendation. The tool’s footer notes that delivered density can differ 15 to 25 percent from its estimate.

What the 1999 Florida Lab Test Found

A 1999 study of six Florida RAP samples reported that lead was detected slightly above the primary drinking water standard. The authors ran batch and column tests. Their column leachate showed no PAHs, VOCs or selected metals above groundwater levels.

Both results describe laboratory tests on Florida material. Neither one is a field measurement of millings placed on a road or drive.

What the 2022 UF Report Found and Concluded

A 2022 University of Florida Hinkley Center report found that risk-based thresholds were exceeded for PAHs and metals in some samples. The authors still wrote that the results suggest RAP poses “minimal risk to human health and the environment” for metal and PAH leaching.

The report also says laboratory-scale studies are built to model leaching risk conservatively. The authors call further full-scale investigations of leaching critical.

Why the Two Florida Studies Point in Different Directions

The 1999 and 2022 studies do not fully agree. The 1999 study reports lead slightly above a drinking water standard in RAP from older roadways. The 2022 report reports threshold exceedances, yet it calls the risk minimal under its laboratory conditions. Both studies tested Florida material, so neither describes millings from other states.

The 1999 and 2022 Florida studies, side by side Two columns compare two Florida studies. The 1999 study by Brantley and Townsend tested six Florida RAP samples with batch and column tests. It found lead slightly above the primary drinking water standard in RAP from older roadways, at levels that fell over time, and no PAHs, VOCs or selected metals above groundwater levels in column leachate. Its conclusion is not verified in this article. The 2022 UF Hinkley Center report by Bowden and colleagues tested Florida RAP at laboratory scale. It found risk-based threshold exceedances for PAHs and metals in some samples and concluded the risk was minimal for metal and PAH leaching under lab conditions. 1999: Brantley and Townsend 2022: UF Hinkley Center report Samples: six Florida RAP samples Test: batch and column tests Finding: lead slightly above the primary drinking water standard. No PAHs, VOCs or selected metals above groundwater levels in column leachate. Conclusion: not verified here Material: Florida RAP Test: laboratory-scale study Finding: risk-based threshold exceedances for PAHs and metals in some samples. Conclusion: minimal risk for metal and PAH leaching, under lab conditions Each column shows what that study tested and found. The two sources do not reconcile the results.
The two Florida studies test different things, and their conclusions do not match.

Two gaps remain open. This article did not verify stormwater runoff evidence, and it found no readable EPA national policy on RAP. Treat both as open questions rather than settled answers.

What to Check Before You Order Millings

Check where the millings came from, what test results exist, and your state’s RAP rules before you order. The lab studies above used stated conditions, so they cannot settle a specific delivery.

Planning question: where did the millings come from? A start box asks where the millings came from. The left branch, old pavement with lab test data, says to read the sample count, the test type, the conditions and the threshold each test used. The right branch, an unknown or untested source, says to ask the supplier where the material came from and for any test results it has. The chart is a planning question only, not a pass or fail rule. Planning question: where did the millings come from? Where did the millings come from? Yes No Old pavement with lab test data Read the sample count, the test type and the conditions named. Check the threshold each test used. Unknown or untested source Ask the supplier where the material came from. Ask for any test results it has. A planning question only. Neither branch is a pass or fail rule.
Start with the source. The branch you land on sets which questions to ask.
  • Source: Ask where the millings came from.
  • Testing: Ask for any leaching or chemical test results, and which samples they cover.
  • Rules: Ask your state transportation agency for its RAP rules.
  • Quantity: Order on the density the supplier states, since delivered density can vary.
Estimate your tons first

Enter your area and depth in the millings tonnage tool, then work through the source questions above before you buy.

FAQs About Asphalt Millings and the Environment

Are asphalt millings bad for the environment?

The studies do not give a yes or no. Two Florida lab studies from 1999 and 2022 found some metals and PAHs, and they read the risk differently. Results depend on the material and test conditions.

What did the 1999 Florida study find about lead?

It tested six Florida RAP samples and reported lead slightly above the primary drinking water standard in RAP from older roadways. It also reported no PAHs, VOCs or selected metals above groundwater levels in column leachate.

What did the 2022 UF report find, and what did it conclude?

It found risk-based threshold exceedances for PAHs and metals in some samples. The authors still call the risk minimal for metal and PAH leaching, and they note the tests were laboratory-scale.

Do the Florida studies apply to millings in my state?

Not directly. Both studies tested Florida reclaimed asphalt in lab-scale work. The 2022 report says full-scale leaching studies are still needed. Check your state agency’s RAP rules for what applies where you live.

How much reclaimed asphalt goes into new pavement?

The FHWA reports that more than 97 percent of reclaimed asphalt mixture was used in new pavement. The average RAP share by weight in asphalt mixtures rose from 15.6 percent in 2009 to 21.1 percent.

How many tons should I order for 500 square feet at 4 inches?

The Asphalt Millings Calculator gives 6.17 cubic yards and 9.26 tons at 1.50 tons per cubic yard. A 10 percent overage brings the order to 10.19 tons. That is planning arithmetic, not a recommendation.

What should I ask a millings supplier before I order?

Ask where the millings came from and whether any test results exist. Ask for the density the supplier states, since delivered density can differ 15 to 25 percent from planning figures.

Sources and Further Reading

References Used in This Article

The leaching findings here come from lab and column studies with stated conditions, not a field verdict. Ask your state agency for its RAP rules before you order millings. Reviewed for accuracy by Prof. Dr. Khalil Mudassar, PhD. Last updated 2026-11-13.