Helical Piers vs Push Piers for Foundation Repair

Which pier should support a sinking foundation, a helical pier or a push pier? Most of the published material on this question comes from the companies that sell each type. This guide explains how each pier is installed and checked, and where the sources stop.

Quick Answer

Helical piers are turned into the ground with torque, and push piers are driven down until they reach a load-bearing layer. Each type is checked in a different way, and the sources read for this article do not settle which type is better. The question is contested.

How Helical Piers Are Installed

Helical piers are advanced into the soil by turning them, and the installer records torque as they go. CHANCE, a manufacturer, calls these products helical piles, and this article treats the two names as the same thing. The short answer is that a helical pile should advance about one pitch per revolution.

The StructureMag article gives an acceptable margin of 2.5 to 3 inches of advance per revolution. The same article says the pile should advance normally, and it treats a pile that does not advance normally as a special case. That case is covered in the capacity section below.

If you want to see how pier count and cost inputs fit together, try the GeniesMag helical pier estimator. It handles the arithmetic and does not check the installation itself.

Helical pier installation check Three boxes in a row. Step 1: advance the pile about one pitch per revolution. Step 2: record average installation torque, the T in the formula Qult = Kt x T. Step 3: check that advance stays between 2.5 and 3 inches per revolution. A box below step 3 says that if advance is not normal, a load test is needed to find capacity. These steps follow the StructureMag and CHANCE articles. Helical pier installation check, as the sources describe it 1. Advance About one pitch per revolution → 2. Torque Average torque recorded → 3. Check 2.5 to 3 inches per revolution Advance not normal? Use a load test Sequence from the StructureMag and CHANCE articles. Not a code requirement.
Each step has a number or a test named in a source; the load test applies only when advance is not normal.

How Push Piers Are Driven Down

Push piers are driven until the design calls for a certain capacity, and the contractor page says there is no set depth. The page describes driving the tip into dense, load-bearing strata, which it calls the deeper soil layers that hold firm year round.

The same page says push piers need the structure’s weight to drive them. For that reason, it says push piers favor heavier homes. The CHANCE blog says nothing about push piers, so this description rests on one contractor page.

How Each Type Is Checked for Capacity

Helical capacity is estimated from torque, and push capacity is supported by drive-force readings. The two methods are different, and each side is a maker or a contractor. CHANCE gives the helical method in a form the sources call Qult = Kt x T, where T is average installation torque.

The torque factor, Kt, depends on the type and size of the helical pile shaft. CHANCE also says Kt is inversely related to shaft diameter, so the factor decreases as the shaft diameter increases. In CHANCE’s words, Torque can be used as an indirect measure of capacity.

Torque is not the whole story. CHANCE reports that Lutenegger cautioned against using torque correlation as the only predictive method for capacity. CHANCE also states that for tested helical piles and tieback anchors, proof testing governs acceptance. The StructureMag article says torque correlation is not valid for a pile that does not advance normally, and it says to use a load test instead.

For push piers, the contractor page cites drive-force readings as proof. It also says every pier is load-tested during installation. That is an uncited company assertion, and this article does not treat it as verified.

Where Soil Conditions Matter for Each Type

Soil changes how each pier behaves during installation, and the sources describe it in general terms. For helical piers, CHANCE says penetration into dense soil can raise torque during installation. It may require higher-strength shafts for that reason.

For push piers, the target is dense, load-bearing strata, according to the contractor page. Footing depth is a separate question from pier depth. Our guide on how deep footings should be covers footings, not piers.

Planning question before choosing a pier type A start box asks whether the soil has been assessed for a load-bearing layer. Two branches follow. Yes: ask for installation records for each pier, helical or push. No or not known: ask for an assessment before comparing pier types. The chart is a planning question, not a code rule, and the sources set no soil-test requirement. Planning question before choosing a pier type Has the soil been assessed for a load-bearing layer? Yes Ask for installation records for each pier, helical or push No or not known Ask for an assessment before comparing pier types Planning question, not a code rule. The sources set no soil-test requirement.
A planning question, not a code rule.

What the Sources Do and Do Not Settle

The sources read for this article do not settle whether helical or push piers are better. The question is contested. All of the sources come from a manufacturer, a trade publication or a contractor, so none is an independent test.

The CHANCE ratings were not read. Their shaft and torque ratings, the Kt values by shaft size, and the ICC-ES reports ESR-2794 and ESR-4891 were not read in full. The ICC-ES AC358 document was not read either. This article therefore gives no capacity ratings, because none were verified.

Two other claims are also left out. A contractor summary says helical piers anchor with more strength than push piers, but that page was not read in full. A push-pier product’s independent load-test data was not found. The table below lists what each source group says.

What each source group says, by pier type
Option Installation Capacity check Source type
Helical piers Turned in with torque; about one pitch per revolution Torque correlation (Kt x T); proof testing governs acceptance for tested piles Manufacturer (CHANCE) and trade publication (StructureMag)
Push piers Driven to dense, load-bearing strata, with no set depth Drive-force readings cited as proof; load-test claim is uncited Contractor (Dalinghaus)
What to ask a contractor Installed depth; torque or drive logs Kt basis; proof-test records; ICC-ES report number Question list from this article, not a source claim

If you need a shallow footing pad rather than a pier, the sizing question is different. Our spread footing calculator handles pad volume only.

Questions to Ask a Pier Contractor

Ask each contractor for records, not only a sales estimate. The sources point to these checks.

  • Installed depth. Ask how deep each pier went and why. Push piers have no set depth, so the reason matters.
  • Torque or drive logs. Helical crews should show torque for each pier. Push crews should show drive-force readings.
  • Proof-test records. Ask for any load test, including one done because advance was not normal.
  • Kt basis. For helical piers, ask which torque factor and shaft size the design uses.
  • ICC-ES report number. Ask for the report that covers the product, and the engineer’s assessment of the soil.

Pier count is the first arithmetic step. The estimator counts piers as length divided by spacing, rounded up, plus one end pier. Its example uses a 120 ft line with piers every 6 ft: 120 / 6 = 20, plus 1 gives 21 piers. The 6 ft spacing is that example’s input, not a spacing rule these sources verify.

Run your own pier count

Open the pier estimator and enter your own length and spacing. It does the arithmetic only, and it does not replace an engineer’s assessment.

FAQs About Helical and Push Piers

What is the main difference between helical piers and push piers?

Helical piers are turned into the ground with torque, while push piers are driven down to a load-bearing layer. The sources describe each type’s proof method differently, so the choice needs a site-specific assessment.

Are helical piers better than push piers?

The sources do not settle that question, and the debate is contested. Every source read here comes from a manufacturer, a trade publication or a contractor, so none is an independent test.

What does torque tell you about a helical pier?

CHANCE says torque can be used as an indirect measure of capacity. Its method multiplies average installation torque by a torque factor, Kt, which depends on shaft type and size.

Is torque alone enough to prove a helical pier holds?

No. CHANCE reports that Lutenegger cautioned against using torque correlation as the only predictive method. CHANCE also says proof testing governs acceptance for tested helical piles.

What if a helical pier will not advance normally?

The StructureMag article says torque correlation is not valid for a pile that does not advance normally. It says to use a load test to find the capacity accurately.

How do push pier contractors show a pier is holding?

Push pier contractors cite drive-force readings as proof. The contractor page also claims every pier is load tested, but that claim is uncited and not verified.

Do push piers suit every house?

The contractor page says push piers need the structure’s weight to drive, so they favor heavier homes. No source read here says they suit every house or soil, so ask an engineer.

Sources and Further Reading

References Used in This Article

Helical and push pier claims come from the makers and contractors named in Sources. The article gives no capacity ratings, because none were verified. Reviewed for accuracy by Prof. Dr. Khalil Mudassar, PhD. Last updated 2026-11-11.